I do not think that they need to be a good person, however, they do have to be likeable.
It happens a lot in media with villains, they may be horrible and unforgiving, but if the character has charisma, it will end up with fans.
Yes! Omg, when I replayed My Forged Wedding this year, I was so shocked to read that Takao was my age. It was a gut punch because I first played the game in my teens. Now I am the same age as one of the oldest LIs.
I think both options bring something unique.
Option A has the advantage of remembering everything that just happened as well as having the emotions and feelings fresh. It can also be used to continue to build intrigue by revealing enough but not all.
Option B tends to allow for the story to...
The pettiest reason has been because the character was really popular, so of course most of the bonus content was of him, it became so annoying that just seeing him irritated me...
I don't really mind if there is no voice acting, but the other two are essential for maintaining my interes in a game. If the story is bad or the characters are boring I may drop the game
Oof, that's hard, but I'll have to go for the story. Although I tend to play otomes for the romance, I think I would be more motivated to finish a game for the story than just relying on the chemistry.
I kinda prefer when there is no gameplay or the gameplay is simple, stat heavy otomes seem like a drag. Besides, the story and characters are what matters to me.
I like both, but it also depends of the genre. A slice of life works best with an everyday otome, while a drama filled works best with a fantasy setting
Weak writing. I am of the belief that anything can work IF you know how to write it properly, but I don't think most people can handle it properly. For example, an irredimable LI or a controversial thrope.
I personally do not love them, I feel that it takes value from the non true routes, besides theres a chance that I will not like the personality of the LI, which makes having to do the route feel punishing