I read this thread, got curious and did some digging around.
The issue MIGHT have stemmed from
another sub -
in which the owner has been actively promoting their sub. The thing is, that other sub is public. It CAN be found with Google searches, and the more people post in there, make comments and upvotes etc. the more attraction it will gain.
I don't know the why and how it happened because I didn't follow it from the beginning, anyway many posts are from otome gamers. Such as these
OVER REQUIEMZ,
7'Scarlet,
DesperaDrops and
Illusion of Itehari posts. Plus
this post where both the private sub and Discord links are out in the open. Other posts with most activities are about Pokemon scarlet (
post 1 and
post 2)
Reading the comments under Itehari, the owner seems to have beef with some people. If these people are really doing what they claim they're doing, that means they've been
reporting both the sub and Discord server. It's a consequence of dangling a donation form in front of their nose and triggering those who think piracy should be free.
Adding fuel to the fire are the Pokemon posts. Needless to say, having a big franchise name provides unnecessary exposure.
Even if the owner doesn't attach a direct link to their sub in new public comments, a glance at the donation form is all it takes to know the private sub's address. That is not much different from directly advertising it
Still, I could be wrong. Unless the owner themselves give details, we can't know where the issue comes from. Best case scenario is nothing will come out of the reports. But making a group for illegal piracy content on a controlled platform like Reddit or Discord is risky to begin with, you're at the mercy of those platforms' policies. The Reddit admins can sneeze one day and the entire sub will be gone.
Lastly, I'm not sure whether those people requesting otome games came from Anime-sharing, but
those requests should be stopped. The latest one was just 1 month ago. They accomplish nothing other than drawing more attention. Aside from rare cases - that are graciously covered by AS co-purchase group, most games get dumped sooner or later anyway.