Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

What do you think about BL elements appearing in otome works?

Yuki3548

Active member
Elite
極乙女
May 1, 2025
367
795
I can't accept it at all! I'm absolutely disgusted by BL storylines being added into otome! even if the characters aren't the main ones, it's still not okay, There shouldn't be any BL elements in otome works, not even a single bit! (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
 
And just to be clear, the same goes for BL, I also don't agree with adding otome elements to BL works. They already have their own space so why do they need to invade someone else's territory?
But if otome elements ever showed up in a BL work, it would be met with immediate backlash. Yet on the otome side, the fanbase is obviously much weaker in terms of fighting power, that's exactly why so many otome openly add BL content to provoke us, they see us as easy targets.
 
If it meant to fit in the story (like a one/off joke) that only last for couple of lines. I'm okay with it. I move past it quickly.

I still vividly remember reading Hiiro no kakera there is a whole BL misunderstanding with CG. I pretty much went... Uhhhh, okay.....
That was a pretty weird experience for me even though I do consume BL works. It's the same feeling I order a matcha drink but was given lemon soda...
 
its a surprisingly complex topic, because if you express even the slightest discomfort with bl ships in otome (rightfully so), you immediately get labeled as a terrible human being who kicks puppies for fun (r/otomegames is a cesspool. they allow opinions that support bl headcanons, but they immediately shut off any discussion on how bl shippers should stay away from otome?). and isnt it interesting how only otome games get affected? you dont see much boy x girl action in bl games, right? bishoujoge treat yuri/lesbians like a fetish (or lesbian/bisexual characters get exploited for unfunny gags) so they dont count. and dont get me started on r18 yuri titles LOL

ultimately, i just dont see a single good reason to mix the genres. considering how otome as a whole leans heavily into selfshipping/yumejoshi territory, shipping two love interests (or love interest and npc, or two npcs) together goes against the entire premise. why not just play bl if you wish for some bxb action? though i know its a hobby for fujoshi to invade fandoms for media that werent made for them, so i shouldnt even be surprised.. but its still frustrating!!

kinda related to the topic, but i also dont want any bisexual lis in otome. im bisexual myself, and i know how much bisexuality gets shit on (like "all bisexuals are cheaters" or "all bisexuals are just gay/straight" or outright "bisexuality doesnt exist"), but why would that be a valuable information in a fictional setting? i want this man to fall in love with me only!! or at least never being touched by another man!! is it really that difficult!!!!! why must i endure this stuff in the only genre made specifically for me!!!!!!!!!

also kinda related to the topic, but IM SO TIRED of seeing bl subplots in romance shoujo manga too!!!!!! oshi ni amagami is a HUGE offender in this, because not only the protagonist doesnt stop any bl moves, but she outright encourages them to spend time together! while knowing about that this dude is in love with her man!! why would i be interested in this?? and its not just this, theres also champignon witch, which has entire volumes dedicated to some bl ship, noraneko to ookami which also has some related topics (doesnt help that the mangaka also has some bl manga on the side) and many more!!

why is everything so male-centered? wouldnt it make way more sense to explore yuri feelings in joseimuke instead?
 
I find them unnecessary and at times disrespectful -looking at you, virche evermore-

I personally wouldn't mind if it was relevant to say, idk, there are side characters with diverse orientations if the world setting and story really need it but otherwise I'd rather not have them mixed in at all. Chances are, if it's a commercial otome game from japanese devs and not an amare clinging to the tag for marketing, it's going to be handled pretty badly after all, so it's best for them to just... not even think about it. In general I wish they could just handle it with sensitivity and actual respect for both the topic and the audience instead of shoehorning it because it might be a writer's fetish or just a way to add "flavor" and have it as a side dish (?? a decoration to straight romance, which is the focus of otome in the first place. No I will never stop being mad about the Virche thing and whoever greenlit that particular plotline was lowkey insane.
It's an even bigger no from me if they're gonna pull a grmn... go awayyyy away awaaaaaay.
I'm also generally wary of a good portion of the fujoshi fandom. They kinda scare me ngl, and some of them are so rude it makes me feel aversion to BL communities so I avoid them if I can help it.

Anyway, it's best to keep the genres separate. BL is popular everywhere as it is and there's barely any otome content available out there these days. Somehow some people out there thinks being a woman otaku = liking, no, being crazy about BL because many BL fans go like: "GAY ROMANCE!!! YAY GOOD IDEA NOW MAKE IT GAY!! It's so much better because uwu the dynamic isn't directed at a *gasps* woman!!!" and like... not every one of us likes BL? Some of us just don't care about it?? And I feel so weird when I get immediately associated with that weird fujo group, not even the normal fujo group T.T, whenever I tell anyone I like anime-adjacent things...

I find this topic very interesting though? Because a lot of people equate not wanting BL in a straight romance to being homophobic when it's really not the case? And brings up a lot of other questions too, like why is it the genre directed explicitly at women the only one expected to make space for men? Why don't the BL fans support the devs who are making the content they're looking for instead of trying to forcing it in the genre explicitly directed at women who want to enjoy straight romance?

A lot of people like to turn it into the oppression olympics too lmao, it comes up all the time in the LADS discourse of people wanting sooo badly for there to be a male MC like "Of course it doesn't matter if the MC isn't a woman, women aren't the only ones going through those things, you know!" And yes, women and other LGBTQ+ folk have gone and do go through nefarious things, but this story is SPECIFICALLY ABOUT WOMEN there's no need to compete when something is, for once, about women lol.

If anything, I wish we had more yuri-otome. Yuri aimed at women who love women. Otome is a genre for women. Aimed at women! About women! And who do women love? Men, other women, and nonbinary folks. Maybe just one, maybe two, maybe all of them, maybe none (but aroace women are kinda left out?? since the focus of the genre is romance lol I think that would be a different topic with a different lens). The conversation on inclusivity in otome contents should be about diverse women with diverse experiences including who they love and what lives they have and can lead as they enjoy love stories, not whether Male NPC A likes Male NPC B or, authors forbid, a romanceable character.
 
Somehow some people out there thinks being a woman otaku = liking, no, being crazy about BL because many BL fans go like: "GAY ROMANCE!!! YAY GOOD IDEA NOW MAKE IT GAY!! It's so much better because uwu the dynamic isn't directed at a *gasps* woman!!!" and like... not every one of us likes BL? Some of us just don't care about it?? And I feel so weird when I get immediately associated with that weird fujo group, not even the normal fujo group T.T, whenever I tell anyone I like anime-adjacent things...
its kinda weird how being insane about bl is considered a good thing, but if a woman expresses her desire to be pampered/praised/loved by a fictional man, she immediately gets written off as a dumb cringy person. ew you want this male character to love YOU instead of another male? embarrassing!! and this is considering how the west tried to hop on the yumejoshi train! who is the weirdo in this scenario??

I find this topic very interesting though? Because a lot of people equate not wanting BL in a straight romance to being homophobic when it's really not the case? And brings up a lot of other questions too, like why is it the genre directed explicitly at women the only one expected to make space for men? Why don't the BL fans support the devs who are making the content they're looking for instead of trying to forcing it in the genre explicitly directed at women who want to enjoy straight romance?
funnily enough gacha game devs see who spends money the most, and its definitely NOT fujoshi lol. why do you think there are so few bl gacha? or why commercial bl is releasing pretty slowly lately? because these people prefer to fight strangers on the internet instead of spending money to support the genre they love. i dont consider myself a fujoshi, im just a casual fan of bl, but im pretty sure throughout my lifetime i spent more money on bl stuff than some of these fujoshi who cry about female mcs in otome LOLOL
 
r/otomegames
Pretty much, yeah. They like to have this very positive vibe but then are really passive-aggressive on anyone who's not on the same page as them, be that self-inserters or the "crazy CN players". Whenever a topic from the CN fanbase makes it there, like the rules of the community with their national games and their inner conflicts between the self-inserters and the female lead party folk, or a recent incident with a cosplayer they just... leave it all at wow they're so delusional it's embarrassing instead of looking at the bigger picture and sociocultural context outside of fandom that is, indeed, relevant to understanding how they came to that point... And anytime this is brought up, they just ignore them :( it's just the impression I have from looking at the sub from time to time for quick news and sometimes fanarts and memes though.
 
also kinda related to the topic, but IM SO TIRED of seeing bl subplots in romance shoujo manga too!!!!!! oshi ni amagami is a HUGE offender in this, because not only the protagonist doesnt stop any bl moves, but she outright encourages them to spend time together! while knowing about that this dude is in love with her man!! why would i be interested in this?? and its not just this, theres also champignon witch, which has entire volumes dedicated to some bl ship, noraneko to ookami which also has some related topics (doesnt help that the mangaka also has some bl manga on the side) and many more!!

why is everything so male-centered? wouldnt it make way more sense to explore yuri feelings in joseimuke instead?
Also, 私がモテてどうすんだ is another example. Before the heroine even became pretty, she was secretly fantasizing about the male leads getting together, After she lost weight and transformed into a beauty, she infiltrated their circle and kept fantasizing about them being with each other, even though all the male leads were actually in love with her. The most disgusting part is that in the end, she gets together with one of the male leads, while the rest of the main characters just get paired off with each other 😅.
 
Pretty much, yeah. They like to have this very positive vibe but then are really passive-aggressive on anyone who's not on the same page as them, be that self-inserters or the "crazy CN players".
this sub was ruined a couple of years ago when someone posted a yaoi fanart and it got rightfully reported. after that mods rewrote the definition of otome in their rules, which is why the entire place is now overrun by either fujoshi who constantly discuss which lis they would love to see do each other (because fuck heroine am i right?) or amare devs who shamelessly promote their games where female mc has less screentime and less love interest than male mc

them just outright attacking cn players is always insane though. i wouldnt say im knowledgeable about chinese culture, but just following the cn otome community for a couple of months, i can see and understand their rules and guidelines and why they are the way they are. do i agree with everything they do and say? not exactly. do i think they are dumb and stupid and their rules must be thrown into trash? hell no! at least cn girls actually bother to protect the genre, unlike for example jp シチュボ community, which expresses their displeasure but still keeps buying works from their hated circles LMAO (i know grmn buys bot reviews and inflates its purchases, but they still have a huge following of real people)
 
Also, 私がモテてどうすんだ is another example. Before the heroine even became pretty, she was secretly fantasizing about the male leads getting together, After she lost weight and transformed into a beauty, she infiltrated their circle and kept fantasizing about them being with each other, even though all the male leads were actually in love with her. The most disgusting part is that in the end, she gets together with one of the male leads, while the rest of the main characters just get paired off with each other 😅.
this manga is actually written by a bl author, so im not surprised at all LMAO
i loved her bl works back in middle school, but never in a thousand years am i gonna touch this particular manga of hers haha
 
but if a woman expresses her desire to be pampered/praised/loved by a fictional man, she immediately gets written off as a dumb cringy person.
LITERALLY a lot of the wall-type/3rd POV players usually have this weird... not like other girls vibe to their words?? Like there's a good handful of them that aren't just enjoying it from a 3rd POV like a normal person, they clearly feel a certain type of way about women wanting to be loved in their fantasies. It really does make one wonder about stuff. I personally never understood the appeal of BL directed at women like... idk? I'm the self-insert/projecting type, but even if I wasn't I just don't get what about BL should make me that insane... specifically because I'm a woman? Or like, excited? Like I've enjoyed kiis fanservice in Blue Lock because the intensity of the rivalry heightened the stakes of the soccer matches lmao and wanted to be in between them but other than that very specific case no BL content has ever done anything for me HAHA. It's just a preference, I'm clearly not the target demographic. I think I wouldn't feel this weirdly if BL wasn't mostly created to please female audiences. If it was just romance about men that wasn't created and marketed specifically for women I mean.


its definitely NOT fujoshi
I'm pretty sure the fujoshi who actually carry fandoms and franchises on their backs are the ones who flock to other, more general stuff? Like at least in my experience, they hang out on every piece of media and when they get invested, they go all out, spending their money, making fanart and fanfiction out of love and enjoyment... unlike the weirdos who cry GIMME BL IN OTOME GAMES!! LIKE DUDE WHY DOES OTOGE ATTRACT SO MANY WEIRDOS it's actually fun to think about it.
 
LITERALLY a lot of the wall-type/3rd POV players usually have this weird... not like other girls vibe to their words?? Like there's a good handful of them that aren't just enjoying it from a 3rd POV like a normal person, they clearly feel a certain type of way about women wanting to be loved in their fantasies. It really does make one wonder about stuff. I personally never understood the appeal of BL directed at women like... idk? I'm the self-insert/projecting type, but even if I wasn't I just don't get what about BL should make me that insane... specifically because I'm a woman?
i dunno. it just sounds like a logic of a three year old child. "girls love boys, boy + boy = double love from girl right???????" as if girls dont yearn for love as well. and this "yaoi helped women to explore their sexuality without being exploited/objectified themselves" nonsensical argument that STILL gets brought up to this day is so stupid too because like. you know otome games and shoujo manga and even yuri manga are primarily written by women right. with women/girls in mind right. and they feature straight romance with good men (except for yuri obviously) right. its not 80s anymore. you actually have freedom of choice. what
I'm pretty sure the fujoshi who actually carry fandoms and franchises on their backs are the ones who flock to other, more general stuff? Like at least in my experience, they hang out on every piece of media and when they get invested, they go all out, spending their money, making fanart and fanfiction out of love and enjoyment... unlike the weirdos who cry GIMME BL IN OTOME GAMES!! LIKE DUDE WHY DOES OTOGE ATTRACT SO MANY WEIRDOS it's actually fun to think about it.
this maaaayyyybe works in shounen, but also a MASSIVE chunk of support comes from yumejoshi. theyre just way less loud on social media, but they are always present, everywhere. people still think that female otaku = fujoshi, which is why people always joke about yaoi and fujoshi saving their manga, and that creates the illusion of yumejoshi never doing any stuff ever. but even the very blue lock community has its fair share of yumejoshi? which is natural, because its full of pretty boys? yet yumejoshi never get any credit for their support. can you guess why? (misogyny and malecentrism, thats why)

also, a good portion of these fujoshi still ride the influence of older fujoshi who "saved" gundam like 20 or 30 years ago. but theyre not them anymore. fujoshi who think they can save otome games or genuinely believe that adding male mc to an otome would result in doubled revenue are. uh. i only have bad words on the tip of my tongue so please finish this sentence yourself (im sorry)
 
I find them unnecessary and at times disrespectful -looking at you, virche evermore-

I personally wouldn't mind if it was relevant to say, idk, there are side characters with diverse orientations if the world setting and story really need it but otherwise I'd rather not have them mixed in at all. Chances are, if it's a commercial otome game from japanese devs and not an amare clinging to the tag for marketing, it's going to be handled pretty badly after all, so it's best for them to just... not even think about it. In general I wish they could just handle it with sensitivity and actual respect for both the topic and the audience instead of shoehorning it because it might be a writer's fetish or just a way to add "flavor" and have it as a side dish (?? a decoration to straight romance, which is the focus of otome in the first place. No I will never stop being mad about the Virche thing and whoever greenlit that particular plotline was lowkey insane.
Right now I'm only worried about Crazy Chain I hope it doesn't have the same kind of plot (because I really love its art style), It's from the same team that made Virche Evermore, and the story setting is also connected.(づ-̩̩̩-̩̩̩_-̩̩̩-̩̩̩)づ
 
I dislike bl in otome. Better separate. I've played the Pretender Guild western otome/bl game and chose to play as a girl + girl voice. But on Cg and mini portraits she was male..... I was shocked when she took off her clothes in the river and had male chest haha Still she spoke female voice. Mc didn't care she is nude with other guys . It was so weird.
 
I mean gay people exist XD I'm fine with secondary romances no matter the type of couple. If it's about the main romance, I can understand it not being to everyone's liking, and I also think in general keeping the genre separate makes for a better result (but that doesn't mean it can't be done well, and I'd totally be up for it if it were so).
 
I find this absolutely unacceptable. The whole point of an otome game is that the protagonist is female. BL is about men with men; putting BL elements in an otome game feels like the female lead is just being used as a 'human camera' for their romance.
If you want BL, play a dedicated BL game. Or, just make a game with a selectable gender. Otome games have a clearly defined female lead—trying to market it as 'otome' while shoving BL in there makes zero sense. I don't get it at all
 
It was a popular trope in otome manga, but I have never seen bl in otome games. Heard about Virche, does it even exist somewhere else?

I'm not against it if it's not about main characters. If side characters are involved - it's just a background for main plot, it can act as comparison for main couple, or give story an unusual perspective
 
its a surprisingly complex topic, because if you express even the slightest discomfort with bl ships in otome (rightfully so), you immediately get labeled as a terrible human being who kicks puppies for fun (r/otomegames is a cesspool. they allow opinions that support bl headcanons, but they immediately shut off any discussion on how bl shippers should stay away from otome?). and isnt it interesting how only otome games get affected? you dont see much boy x girl action in bl games, right? bishoujoge treat yuri/lesbians like a fetish (or lesbian/bisexual characters get exploited for unfunny gags) so they dont count. and dont get me started on r18 yuri titles LOL

ultimately, i just dont see a single good reason to mix the genres. considering how otome as a whole leans heavily into selfshipping/yumejoshi territory, shipping two love interests (or love interest and npc, or two npcs) together goes against the entire premise. why not just play bl if you wish for some bxb action? though i know its a hobby for fujoshi to invade fandoms for media that werent made for them, so i shouldnt even be surprised.. but its still frustrating!!

kinda related to the topic, but i also dont want any bisexual lis in otome. im bisexual myself, and i know how much bisexuality gets shit on (like "all bisexuals are cheaters" or "all bisexuals are just gay/straight" or outright "bisexuality doesnt exist"), but why would that be a valuable information in a fictional setting? i want this man to fall in love with me only!! or at least never being touched by another man!! is it really that difficult!!!!! why must i endure this stuff in the only genre made specifically for me!!!!!!!!!

also kinda related to the topic, but IM SO TIRED of seeing bl subplots in romance shoujo manga too!!!!!! oshi ni amagami is a HUGE offender in this, because not only the protagonist doesnt stop any bl moves, but she outright encourages them to spend time together! while knowing about that this dude is in love with her man!! why would i be interested in this?? and its not just this, theres also champignon witch, which has entire volumes dedicated to some bl ship, noraneko to ookami which also has some related topics (doesnt help that the mangaka also has some bl manga on the side) and many more!!

why is everything so male-centered? wouldnt it make way more sense to explore yuri feelings in joseimuke instead?
I completely agree. The subject of an otome game should be a woman, and the romantic development must revolve around her. This cannot be deviated from; otherwise, the heroine becomes nothing more than a camera. Such a game shouldn't even be called an otome game. The reason I think yuri is reasonable within otome games is that the emotional development still deeply involves the heroine.「(゚ペ)
 
I hate it. It's just destroying the whole genre. that's very disrespectful to the creator of the otome genre. because the gaming world is all taken over by men, and this genre was created to be a safe place for women.
 
I hate it — it even makes me feel sick. Why would an otome game include BL elements?
Slightly off-topic, but there was a doujin circle on DLsite called がるまにオリジナル (乙女) that added male-male contact in one of their audio works. It made me feel completely disgusted. A work aimed at a female audience — and they put BL in it. If they really want to write BL, they should start a new series, not turn characters with a normal orientation into having guy-on-guy contact in a sequel. That's just a betrayal of the listeners.
 
I personally can't accept BL elements in an otome game.
To me, otome games are about the heroine forming romantic relationships with the male characters.
If those same male characters start developing romantic or sexual relationships with each other, it completely breaks my immersion.
It makes me feel like the "rivals" are now more interested in each other than in the heroine — and that's not the dynamic I signed up for. 😅
 
I like BL, but I don't really like it when it shows up in otome works. I can accept it if it serves a purpose in the story, though.
Also, as with the Haruhara ending in CLANNAD, if the conditions for entering a route are difficult but the content is comedic, I can overlook it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yuki3548
Between NPCs, it's honestly whatever. But if it involves any LI, no, absolutely not. That's not otome. Not just BL, actually, I also don't like seeing games that call themselves otome but have a female LI. We have separate genres for a reason.