[News]FBI Official: Suspicionless Surveillance is Ineffective and Counterproductive

Not open for further replies.


A.C Milan Fan Club
Elite Member
Feb 24, 2012
This week a high-level FBI official made some welcome comments on the NYPD's spying on New York City's Muslim communities and organizations that mirror the ACLU's own position on the suspicionless surveillance.

As you know, we at the ACLU we have long raised concerns about increasing levels of suspicionless surveillance by law enforcement and intelligence agencies, whether enabled though legislation, like the Patriot Act, Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Amendments Act, or proposed cybersecurity bills; or though policy and programs, like the amendments to Attorney General Guidelines (AGG) governing the FBI, state and local intelligence fusion centers, and "suspicious activity reporting" programs, to name but a few.

The ACLU's argument is suspicionless surveillance inappropriately invades the privacy of innocent persons and failing to require a factual basis creating reasonable suspicion and probable cause before initiating surveillance opens the door to biased policing, leading to unconstitutional racial and religious profiling and spying on political activists in violation of their First Amendment rights.

Based on my experience in law enforcement, I have also argued that suspicionless surveillance is ineffective and counterproductive as a security measure because it fills intelligence databases with useless information and undermines community support for legitimate law enforcement and intelligence activities directed at real threats.

Now, we are heartened to hear that the FBI agrees with us (or at least one high-level FBI official does). Newark, N.J., FBI Special Agent in Charge (SAC) Michael Ward has spoken out in opposition to the NYPD spying program:

"But (the NYPD) coming out and just basically mapping out houses of worship and minority-owned businesses, there's no correlation between the location of houses of worship and minority-owned businesses and counterterrorism" work, he continued. Ward also said there should be "an articulable factual basis" for domestic intelligence collection, such as a 'specific reason why we're looking at this location, this person'."
He went on to describe the negative impact these types of operations have on the FBI's relationship with the Muslim community. We couldn't agree more and are pleased to have an FBI official of Ward's stature and experience making such a clear denunciation of suspicionless surveillance.

Unfortunately, the view that both Ward and the ACLU share isn't reflected in the FBI's policies, or its practices. To the contrary, FBI policies permit the kind of surveillance Ward rightly criticizes. The FBI's guidelines were changed in 2008 to remove the requirement of any factual predicate before the FBI initiates intrusive investigations, and the FBI has a "racial and ethnic mapping" program targeting racial, ethnic and religious groups all across the country. In Newark, the FBI used census data to identify and map Latino communities throughout New Jersey in an attempt to assess the threat from MS-13. (We're suing in N.J. because the Newark FBI refused to release other documents in response to our Freedom of Information Act request for racial mapping data).

In fact, the FBI's modified guidelines allow the same type of abusive surveillance the NYPD engaged in, without any factual predicate, and our nationwide FOIA has revealed FBI agents targeting Muslim communities in Detroit, the Chinese and Russian-American communities in San Francisco, and tracking the growth of the Black population in Georgia. The FBI also used community outreach programs as a guise to collect information about the First Amendment activities of peaceful Muslim groups in Northern California for intelligence and investigative purposes.
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest profile posts

Mero Mero wrote on Ryzen111's profile.
Hello, Ryzen111. could you reupload mexashare [ONEONE1] 露出系肉便器3パック thx
xijue wrote on Stetmann's profile.
対魔忍ドラマCD.part18.rar - 2.0 GB File cannot be downloaded,Invalid link: The file is out of date or deleted,
Can you send me another copy?I really, really need this file。
081569 wrote on Otokonoko's profile.
Hello, could you upload
Foulo_paints]ブ〇アカ Live2Dアニメーション プ〇ナ[RJ01214325]?
bandi1 wrote on girlcelly's profile.
Can I re-seed
I've been looking for this material for months, but it's not seeding.
If you re-seed, I'll sign up for your Repidgator link.
Sincerely, please.
Seruju wrote on Shine's profile.
Hi Shine,

Could you reup this one?
[230224] [枕] サクラノ刻 ―桜の森の下を歩む― 通常版 + 特典 (Crack)