I mean, there's nothing better than having the LI scream over MC's death, no?
I think bad endings, if done well, can leave a deeper emotional impact. There's something enjoyable about seeing what "breaks" a character, it can reveal a lot about them. That said, I still prefer comfort... So I enjoy bad endings, but at the end of the day the good ends win because I'm an idealist and I want all things to end well lol