I crave fantasy otome, although I like everyday otome it hits close to reality for my liking, and since I'm a big DnD player I loooooove anything fantasy, just to be able to see mystical characters and world setting makes me happier because it doesn't have anything to hit close to home yk, it's refreshing and I do love a good character with horns or ears, vampires as well!
I'm a adult so school settings tend to me harder to catch my attention (idk about you but I don't miss my school days lol), but mafia (which I consider a bit of a everyday otome) are quite of my liking.
One example that has everyday and fantasy in one game is Diabolik Lovers and although I'm not a fan of school settings I did like the game. I do wish we had more games with dragons and cat men ugh, I love tails and wings