I keep love catch on, mostly because that's usually the default option. Yes, sometimes (if I'm not using a walkthrough) it does give me the urge to reload if I pick the "wrong" choice, but I resist and continue. Plus, I would prefer to know the effect of each choice and how it's considered or viewed in the story because that helps to understand it better based on which choices raise affinity, whether a choice is considered "good" or "bad" (or any other variable), etc, because then I get a better idea on the stance/angle of the narrative and what it's trying to convey. It's also helpful in terms of accessibility if I'm trying to get a specific ending without using a guide.