Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

A naive otome protagonist

I feel like it depends on the age. If the MC's a student, then yeah, it's fine that they're clueless about some stuff. But if they're 25+ and still acting like a child?? Bro... that's just cringe 💀
 
I believe it's contingent upon the plot. On the assumption that the mc grew up being mistreated, it is totally inevitable.. in addition to that I don't think we can blame her in the case of suffering multitudinous trauma.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Hinamori Amu
There are both good and bad representations of having a naive Fl. In my opinion, I don't really like gullible Fls. I find that they are way too prevalent in media these days.😔😔

A good instance could be if eventually she learns and grows from her naivety. Taking her mistakes and using them to better herself. Usually though, that is never the case😒. In the end, the Fl will continue to cling on to her LI. Forever cast in the shadows of those who continue to better themselves.
 
It's not that I dislike naive protagonists, but it can be a bit frustrating to watch one who ends up feeling apologetic even when it's clearly the other person who's in the wrong.
 
I do get annoyed when the heroine is overly naive. I have to bring up the heroine in Nil Admirari no Tenbin — her logic is so confusing and she's far too naive that I couldn't keep going. I dropped the game during the common route. After that, I started avoiding scenarios written by Katagiri Yuma.
 
I dont mind naive heroines I adore them along with the bold ones but yes its frustrating when they do something stupid 😅
 
I have a very strong opinion on this, though it has never particularly bothered me. I believe that every protagonist—whether in terms of personality or way of thinking—fits well within their story; it's all a matter of balance. Sometimes a story requires a protagonist who is 'innocent' in order for the plot to unfold—though perhaps 'good-hearted' is a more accurate term.
 
MC-prefix characters with strong personalities—because, in my experience playing multiple times, those with submissive character traits tend to take that aspect of their personality to an extreme.
 
I think it really depends on the game, so I wouldn't put all naive or passive protagonists into the same category. A kind and innocent protagonist can work really well in an otome game, especially since it allows her to connect with a wide range of love interests. Of course, I can understand why some people might find that type of protagonist frustrating. Both conventional and unconventional protagonists can be compelling depending on how well they're written!
 
I just don't like when they are too forgiving of others or easily manipulated. I especially care more when she's paired with a more rude, cruel or tsundere type LI. I don't want to see her be a punching bag for insults, in these cases I'd rather see her stand her ground or quip back.
 
What matters most to me is that the heroine isn't stupid and knows how to handle herself in different situations.

Liliana from Piofiore is often called naive, but I think she's actually pretty good at handling situations. Meanwhile, Cyrus from Steam Prison is often praised as a brave, strong-willed heroine, but I dropped the game because I found her really stupid.
 
No, lol. Maybe because there are too many "strong female MC" now these days, to the point they exaggerate it. The concept is similar as you read a Shonen manga/manhwa that has overpowered MC who can beat their enemy easily and just aura farm. There's nothing wrong with it. but I prefer that naive, weak MC with great character development rather than strong MC from the start. Of course the key here is the character development
 
I dont like if they have too much strong personality or too quiet.
I like it if they can balance it when the story progress on.
 
I don't think I would get angry. I like the protagonist to be kind, innocent, and gentle. I feel very protective, and I like the male lead to be more dominant.
 
Yes especially when the MC is so naive that she completely ignores obvious red flags 😭 I don't mind a shy or passive MC as long as her behavior makes sense for her personality but it gets frustrating when she never stands up for herself or lets everyone make decisions for her. I don't need every MC to be strong and independent but I do want her to have some common sense and a mind of her own!
 
Yes..It just feels like the MC has no soul that way.. Also they just look too saintly or brainless in my eyes. It's like the plot is like a sea and the MC is a boat that just go with the flow.... ദ്ദി(⎚_⎚)
 
I can still accept a naive MC, but if they're already treated poorly by supporting characters or LIs, and I'm forced to endure it and even make excuses for their behavior along with the MC, that's a bit much for me.😓
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back