Hajime Saitou is one of the favorite characters in this game—yet, unfortunately, neither my friend nor I liked him. We genuinely wondered if we were missing something
(WARNING: I JUST WROTE A GODDAMN ESSAY ON THIS GUY!!

)
To expand a little on why I love him (I hope it's okay!), I honestly think that if someone isn't into slower and, for lack of a better word, "shyer" romances, they'll have a hard time enjoying Saito's.
When we meet him he appears so sure of his path in life that it feels like he's unreachable, but underneath, like the kuudere he is, he's a big softie who cares *A LOT* about the people he loves and shows this care through the only thing he's sure he's good at: fighting and protecting. (There's also cooking, but everyone has a turn at this so he wouldn't take over because, well... It's basically a rule, and he starts out as very strict regarding rules). He won't be writing love letters, composing poems or singing open praises to us, but he's steady as stone and shows practical support: testing and giving faith of our skills so we would be let out of the compound, even when pursuing Okita's route, and in general, being there to save us, listen to what we want to do and supporting that decision, not to mention— literally stopping by our room to look after us when we're sick while he's in the middle of a SPY MISSION AND WE THINK HE LEFT FOR GOOD. He won't say it openly while we can hear it, but he shows his care through actions that demand no answer and only hope for trust in return. He is a bit more demonstrative in the fandiscs (because duh that's what they're for) and it is mostly framed as little moments of respite while doom starts looming in the horizon, or him being so overwhelmed by the weight of his feelings that he doesn't know what to do with himself. As for more characterization explored in the additional content like live reading events or drama CDs, he's said he would help us get out of the Shinsengumi and cover for us if we ever wanted to leave, and that he would stay behind even knowing being found out would result in seppuku from disobeying orders, and in other cases he's shown as thinking about us when he thinks of his type (to marry) and being in general stress over not being good at connecting with others, be it us or the soldiers of his division. He's full of good intentions but is also bad at socializing, so it makes sense he'll show his love through simple actions and quiet support.
This is just my personal opinion and interpretation, but I think the way the game handled the themes of things that change and things that never change in the dawn of a new era was handled excellently with his route, considering he's based off a real Shinsengumi survivor famous for, precisely, knowing how to adapt as the times changed and lived to old age.
Saito believes in things that never change and these are explored throughout the route: loyalty to those who helped you, to those you choose to believe in, to your own decisions and principles, the connection shared between friends who are aiming in the same direction (he sees the group collapse little by little and does what he can to keep the dream they fought for upright, and later, his friends come to the rescue in the final fight of his route), and of course, loving someone (from him to us and from us to him).
However, just like those things that never change exist precisely because they never change, many other things *do* change: the nature of the bonds shared between people, people themselves, the tide of time and ideals at large. As everything starts changing around him, the only answer he's most sure of upholding is protecting the place he belongs to: the Shinsengumi and later the Aizu, thanks to whom a Shinsengumi exists in the first place, even in the face of adversity, living in the margins of history just before the page starts to turn. He carries this heavy responsibility while his own feelings for us have already changed, and because he is aware that things are changing, he can't in good conscience burden us with them and make us go with him unless it is what we choose ourselves, and even then, he'll be left wondering why when we have no responsibility or clear commitment to him like he does to his cause as a soldier.
No promises were exchanged between us precisely because everything was changing faster than we could keep up with, and instead of stopping to acknowledge it (because acknowledging it outright would be facing the truth that the world would collapse and trample us soon enough), we move forward sharing the determination to see things through to the end, whichever it might be. Basically: we are having feelings but we need to deal with the plot. The plot being our family becoming enemies of the state and some of the last bastions of a dead cause.
I also think it very fitting how in this route, for all intents and purposes, the Shinsengumi is the only family we have left. We find out our father is not really our father, and he wants to sell us out to a man who has done nothing but try to kill the people who've cared for us in our father's absence. Living with the Shinsengumi, we've experienced it all: fear, unease, security, support, joy, grief, glory and defeat. After years spent by their side and faced with the betrayal of the man who raised us, a natural conclusion is for us to consider them the place where we belong. We choose to stay because we belong in this group and Saito respects that decision maybe because he understands better than anyone else how that feels. He was, if I recall correctly, shunned by his family after he killed a Hatamoto's son? In a duel, and nowhere but Shiei Hall (later mibu roshi/Shinsengumi) accepted and respected his left-handed kenjutsu despite his clear skill and strength. He, too, has no other place to belong to other than the Shinsengumi. It's a bit poetic that the end result brings us together and we become each other's place of belonging even after everything else has changed and disappeared.
He is, in general, very respectful of our choices and won't try to persuade us otherwise unless the choice involves putting our life in danger, and even then, he only makes sure we know what we're getting into before letting us follow through… except at the climax of the route, when the confession scene happens.
Understandably, he doesn't want us to die because we're important to him. At this point is clear that the Shinsengumi and remaining Shogunate forces are fighting basically to resist being massacred with their arms crossed, and he doesn't want us to get dragged down into it. We're no warrior and should never have had to set foot on a battlefield, so instead of staying in Aizu (where the war was, according to what little I've read about the real events, one of the most brutal in Japanese history at the time), he thinks we have better odds at surviving if we leave with Hijikata (who likely would've also left us behind with doctor Matsumoto as he tried to do in his own route).
At this point he opens up about his insecurities and shortcomings. He moves forward in the path he thinks is the best course of action to stay loyal to what he believes in (unchanging loyalty to those who helped him and those he cares about) while being unsure of whether this is really the right choice. He says it himself, he still thinks he should run after Hijikata and follow him instead, like he suggests we do, and he is no perfect warrior without doubts or uncertainty to his actions. If we've seen him as such, he would rather not sully our memories of him with this weak side of him and let us go on our way, as we have no commitment to him and are free to do as we please—he just wants us to not die in the process.
Once it's clear we're not going anywhere unless it's with him, he takes our sincerity for what it is and responds in earnest with his own, and finally the feelings he didn't dare voice with everything that was at stake have an outlet in a first kiss that seals a promise to stay together, even if the world is about to collapse and trample over us, and the certainty that those feelings will never change no matter what else does, and "for us, as we were ready to head to our demise, there could be no greater happiness". He's chosen to stay with us and allows himself to be selfish by choosing to protect us out of his own will, without relying on someone else's orders or rules. A key characteristic of his is how obstinate he can be about rules and tradition, he has a very rigid thinking pattern in this regard, and his evolution shows when he first decides to stay to fight for the Aizu and then when he decides to respond to our feelings with his own. He's choosing for himself, thinking for himself, in ways he didn't do very much before it came down to this.
I still wonder why the writers chose to make Kazama the Big Villain of the route in the way they did when he's clearly shown as despising Kodo's work with the rasetsu in every other plot line, but in a way I think it also loops back to the characterization they were going for with Saito.
Kazama, largely unbothered by the politics at play and content to let humans kill each other as it has nothing to do with him, in this route pursues his selfish goal of taking us as basically a broodmare, and meets his death at the end of Saito's blade. Saito, on the other hand, has chosen to protect us as his very first selfish goal, as it serves no one but himself and his relationship with us, all while keeping the desire to see things through with the Aizu regardless of what the world at large has already decided will happen to them. In a way, they've both detached themselves from the greater picture in the pursuit of their own goals, except one seeks to harm and the other seeks to protect.
It was also super amazing, in my opinion, how Heisuke, Shinpachi and Sano jump in to help citing the rule of The Code: "Never fight alone," As it symbolizes that the bond between friends who are aiming in the same direction never fades away, even if its nature or appearance must change.
His story does end on a hopeful note. For all the struggles faced in the Boshin War and after, basically exiled in Tonami, eventually we rebuild a new life with him in a world that once collapsed and tried to trample us over, and we survived in spite of it all. Perhaps the fate of the real historical figure also plays a part in how hopeful this ending feels. The way they wrote it felt like a miracle happened, and we survive to live on in peace. Ginsei no Shou, one of the fandiscs, even goes out of its way to show yet again how things that never change and things that do change can and often do go hand in hand. Roughly five years olater, we're expecting our first child at long last and he received an offer and recommendation to work in the Tokyo Metropolitan Police Department, just like his historical counterpart did at some point. Things keep changing, and our feelings and commitment to each other hasn't.
Maybe I could summarize it all like this:
Saito Hajime as a character in Hakuoki is reliable and comforting to me because he's clear about what he means, what he wants and where he's going. His unchanging devotion, commitment and love is explored in a way that leaves space for subtle gestures of care that won't demand an immediate answer from you when things around you are already dire enough to cloud both his and your judgement. But once he knows we both are standing eye to eye, and know exactly what it is we're getting into by committing to each other—for the rest of our lives, be that decades or a month or a day—he won't ever let go or betray that commitment.
As a not so serious thought, it is very funny that the place he drinks blood from is very intimate and… stimulating… and how even when he's holding himself back emotionally, he even has that moment when he keeps suckling on our ear long after the wound has closed. He clearly has desires and wants of his own, but he's so unused to handling himself without guidelines, he doesn't know what to do… how cute… he's so repressed it's funny to see. He could've drank from a finger, from our hand, or arm, or whatever, but no, HE went and said wait lemme do it and went right for our ear… like ok Saito this is a safe space you can be honest with yourself, anything you want to share with the class—
I AM SO SORRY FOR THE LONG ASS REPLY

I love yapping about my favorite characters…. congrats to anyone who read all that. Here's a cake

.