For me, it's the art; that's always what draws me in first. Then I look at the plot, and finally, I check the reviews—if most of them are positive, I buy it.
I remember I was on the internet and saw an ad for a My Candy Love game where Nathaniel appeared. I was interested, so I clicked on it and started playing. I liked it because it was in Spanish, and then a friend told me that several anime had their own games, and she recommended a website where...
Yes, if I like an otome or a BL, I would watch it again for the beautiful scenes and to calmly appreciate the details that I didn't notice or didn't pay attention to the first time I played it.