Objectively, Light Mode does indeed meet parameters. but subjectively, it does seem a bit bright to me also, so I'm using Dark Mode.
I'm wondering, would an additional mode, maybe a Light Blue Mode (between Light and Dark) be a possibility?
Understanding your suggestion for a middle-ground, perhaps a 'Light Blue Mode,' let me clarify the complexity involved in this process.
Creating both Light and Dark modes requires careful balance. Each element used on the forum should have a color tone that is neither too bright nor too dark. This balancing act is crucial to ensure legibility in both themes.
Should achieving this balance prove impossible, we would need to create custom profiles for both themes. Managing these separate profiles requires considerable effort due to their different color combinations and, at times, different design elements altogether.
It's important to remember that contrast is what makes one theme feel brighter than the other. Naturally, when comparing light against dark, the light theme will seem much brighter. Take the moon as an example. Against the dark backdrop of space, the moon appears to shine brightly, but it is, in actuality, a dark grey blob.
If you're skeptical of this effect, try using Discord's light theme and compare it to the dark one. The light theme might feel overwhelmingly bright, but it's the contrast between the two that causes this perception.
We remain committed to enhancing your user experience, and your feedback is always valued as we continue to improve our platform.