Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

What do you think about randomized merch/character goods?

wadesta

New member
乙女
Recognized
Dec 4, 2018
28
18
As you guys often see, this is a trick often used by Ot*mate and Rej*t when they're selling their merch. This resulted in reselling prices and their "cheap vs expensive chara" pricing. Hell, I have passed on Rej*t Store in Ikebukuro, and they have NOTHING shaped like merch displayed on their store, as every single thing is wrapped in thick silver wrappings, peculiar to randomized merch.

Now, as someone who studied little to none about economy, I don't understand on why they keep on doing this. At least for myself, this puts me off horribly from buying merch.

On the other side, I still buy merch from Chinese companies that don't do this kind of behavior, and companies/circles that do made-to-order merchs (hi Adelta yes I love you). Accessibility is a big point here, as I'm not that unemployed to be able to use my free time talking keigo to random japanese asking for exchanges.

Tell me what do you think about this phenomenon!
Also, could anyone who has economic knowledge related to this explain to me, on why this happened up until this day??
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't buy it either lol

I'd rather just pay for the exact item I want instead of leaving it up to luck. Because with my luck, I'll definitely end up with a pile of unwanted merch. That just sounds so sad. That merch could be with someone who loves it, and here it's with me, unloved and buried in dust.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zobi
It's a no for me (unless I hako-oshi the specific IP then maybe..?)

They're probably just trying to ride the blind boxes trend, but it seems to be creating a secondhand market of people dissatisfied with what they got.
 
It's annoying because it feels like another easy way to fish for more money, but sadly blind boxes, gachapon, and gacha games are ubiquitous nowadays and never even questioned.
 
I feel the same. I'm not even that big of a merch collector, but when I can't be certain which character I'm getting, I'd rather just save that money and buy something else. It just makes me kind of sad because, if I could, I'd definitely prefer to buy merch directly from the official source rather than having to go through second-hand websites and deal with the ridiculous character specific prices.
 
There was an interview with one of companies (not otome, but selling anime merch) and they said, that this type of buisiness raises sales so much, that no company can abandon it. There are people who won't buy at all, but there also are people who would buy a lot to get their favourite character, and there are people who would buy one or two to try their luck. And it will get more money then when everybody just buy one and stop, sadly.
 
Personally, I think that, since Japanese people have customs such as drawing omikuji to test their luck, they may not feel hesitant about buying items whose contents they cannot see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wadesta
If the merch were cheap, I think I'd still buy randomized items just for the fun of it. But the problem is, they're not cheap at all! 😭 Spending that much on something when you don't even know which character you'll get feels like a lot of pressure.

I can understand why companies do it from a business perspective. Randomized sales encourage fans to buy multiple items in hopes of pulling their oshi, which naturally boosts sales. But still, I really wish they'd offer non-randomized options.

And if they're going to keep selling randomized merch, at least make it REALLY affordable!!
 
Typically, when random merchandise is released, the strategy is to encourage bulk purchases pushing fans to keep buying until they finally get the specific character they want. (like gacha items)
I'm not a fan of that; I prefer to wait until some time has passed and the items become available secondhand or at a lower price. and I don't want to introduce unnecessary hardship into my own hobbies. 🙁
 
I used to buy random merchandise, but I've stopped buying it now.

The trading process takes so much time and effort, and if your favorite character happens to be a high-demand character, it can be really difficult to get what you want… I've just gotten tired of it. 😓

I also felt a little uncomfortable with how high-demand and low-demand characters were treated differently, even though every single character is important in their own way. 😢

That said, I have a friend who absolutely loves random merchandise and used to buy tons of it, so I guess some people really enjoy the excitement of not knowing which character they're going to get! 💦
 
I don't like that so many companies are doing blind box style merchandising, especially when some don't offer any alternatives. It's not consumer-friendly at all. I miss when the default was being able to see what you were buying. To a certain extent, I get that blind merch encourages more spending but the official companies don't even reap the highest benefits from doing this - the scalpers do. 単推し fans are better off commissioning a personal piece of art/goods because if they have to spend extra to guarantee getting their one and only fave, might as well have it be one of a kind and the money can go to a talented creator instead of some bum reseller.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: wadesta
Everyone thank you for answering! It's relieving to hear that most of people are not satisfied with this system, brings me a sliver of hope in this randomized goods hell 💀

There was an interview with one of companies (not otome, but selling anime merch) and they said, that this type of buisiness raises sales so much, that no company can abandon it. There are people who won't buy at all, but there also are people who would buy a lot to get their favourite character, and there are people who would buy one or two to try their luck. And it will get more money then when everybody just buy one and stop, sadly.

I don't like that so many companies are doing blind box style merchandising, especially when some don't offer any alternatives. It's not consumer-friendly at all. I miss when the default was being able to see what you were buying. To a certain extent, I get that blind merch increases encourages more spending but the official companies don't even reap the highest benefits from doing this - the scalpers do. 単推し fans are better off commissioning a personal piece of art/goods because if they have to spend extra to guarantee getting their one and only fave, might as well have it be one of a kind and the money can go to a talented creator instead of some bum reseller.

From these two replies, I see that otome companies, being a niche genre themselves, tend to play safe in this aspect. Especially if they're trying to break even in this niche niche space. Now that I think about it deeper, Chinese companies have a huge mainland population as their potential customer. While small yet kind circles have a possibility to 赤字, and they're just doing it for the love of the game.

It all makes sense when you only think about revenue. But this is a horrible method of keeping your customer's trust, proven in everyone's answers here. Myself also used to want to support these company, until all the frustration stemming from having to trade my way into my fave's merch got better of me. Now I don't even buy their games anymore lmao (even when I have the money to do so).
I just can't comprehend the Japanese business mindset (all that geoblocking and stuff too).

I agree with commissioning artists, but sometimes I also get the desire of having merch that has the same art style as the games that I did. It's pain out there. 😿
 
That just sounds like gambling lol. I don't even like playing gatcha for the same reason, so I really don't like the model, but I'm sure that companies love it
 
I don't buy it LOL. If I REALLY like the art, I just wait for resellers to sell the specific character I like (which is sometimes unfortunate because they jack up the price)
 
That just sounds like gambling lol. I don't even like playing gatcha for the same reason, so I really don't like the model, but I'm sure that companies love it
What's funny is that gacha games don't make their audience gamble for merch, only the in-game stuff is up to chance. In my experience at least (which is mainly with Chinese side of mobile gacha games. I don't interact with the Japanese side since they have lots more non-gacha options to pick from) they handle merchandising better by not only letting people pick exactly what their getting, but also they make everything to order so everyone can get what they want as long as it's within the preorder period. Otomate and other companies that like doing in-person market events always severely understock items. Just take a look at AGF and how every year people complain about everything being sold out immediately despite the booth queues barely moving...