- Nov 22, 2023
- 207
- 453
For me, it is. Personally, I don't think I've enjoyed any other otome game as much so far. Then again, I probably haven't played as many as other people have, so I haven't really found a new favorite yet. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Is the first otome game you played your all-time favorite?
- Thread starter lst
- Start date
- Oct 13, 2023
- 282
- 574
Not really lmao my early otome days were just playing whatever I could get my hands on... and most of the time it wasn't so good ;b
My first otome was the benchmark for a long time for the overall plot and for having multiple fantastic LIs. That's changed now that I've found so many great games that also have unique routes/endings for each LI.
- Aug 30, 2024
- 765
- 1,416
i dont even remember what my first otome was.. was it my candy love? or some mobile game? did i even play mobile games back then? i seriously dont remember ww..;-;
the only titles that i have in the back of my mind are my candy love and hatoful boyfriend. im like 100% sure neither of those were my first otome though
my candy love was,, eh, it was fine, but the monetization was really messing with me. if only i knew how bad its gonna get in the future..;; i really liked the lake house aka the fangame though! sigh so many memories with these characters..
hatoful boyfriend was very fun at first, but then nageki route hit. and then shuu. and then the true route and i was fuckign devastated WWWW. although i wouldnt claim it as my all-time favourite, i still hold it very dear to my heart! maybe i should reread it soon.. after i finish rereading room no.9 at least..
guess im still looking for that ultimate otome game that will completely rewire my brain. luckily there are still tons of otome games to explore, so i cant wait^^
the only titles that i have in the back of my mind are my candy love and hatoful boyfriend. im like 100% sure neither of those were my first otome though
my candy love was,, eh, it was fine, but the monetization was really messing with me. if only i knew how bad its gonna get in the future..;; i really liked the lake house aka the fangame though! sigh so many memories with these characters..
hatoful boyfriend was very fun at first, but then nageki route hit. and then shuu. and then the true route and i was fuckign devastated WWWW. although i wouldnt claim it as my all-time favourite, i still hold it very dear to my heart! maybe i should reread it soon.. after i finish rereading room no.9 at least..
guess im still looking for that ultimate otome game that will completely rewire my brain. luckily there are still tons of otome games to explore, so i cant wait^^
Foxgloves
New member
- May 28, 2020
- 99
- 35
Absolutely not haha. But it definitely has a special place in my heart.
- Dec 27, 2020
- 46
- 36
it was hakuoki for me... i was 8 years old with english being my 3rd language. i had no idea what was going on most of the time. it was above my comprehension level rip
- Mar 2, 2016
- 113
- 85
I don't exactly remember what my first otome game was haha it's been way too long, but I'm pretty sure it was either Amnesia or Starry Sky in Spring. There weren't many otome games available in English at the time and it was also around that time that I learned about otome games. I wouldn't say either one of them is my all time fave, but they are two of my faves and are special to me since that's how I started playing otome games 
Euclase
New member
- May 3, 2026
- 24
- 19
Tokimeki Memorial was the first game I ever played. I'm really grateful they released it. It's not the best game ever, but getting frustrated with the bombs is actually a fond memory.
- Apr 8, 2026
- 61
- 43
Definitely not my favourite but I do hold it close to my heart and still think fondly about it time to time.
- Nov 15, 2025
- 106
- 78
yes, my candy love 
i've been playing since 2012 (when i was still a child
) and although i love many other otome games, it seems like this one will never leave my top 1.
i've been playing since 2012 (when i was still a child
) and although i love many other otome games, it seems like this one will never leave my top 1.
- Dec 2, 2025
- 53
- 44
Nope. My 1st mobile otome game was Shall we date: The Niflheim and my 1st console/pc otome was Amnesia: Memories- I've got a huge soft spot for both but neither of them are my all-time faves.
- Jun 30, 2025
- 149
- 230
not my absolute favorite but i do remember it fondly for being a fun experience and opening my mind that there's a whole world of games about dating guys... thank you for your service re:alistair i love it here
- May 20, 2025
- 61
- 48
my first otome is not my absolute favorite but it's definitely one that i hold very close to my heart for introducing me to the genre that i now love so much
- Jul 16, 2021
- 153
- 165
Amnesia was my first, it has a special place in my heart but I will not say that it is my favorite.
- Apr 8, 2025
- 248
- 947
Haha no as the first ones I remember were mobile ones then the first sort of serious one was Sweet Fuse and Hakuouki which are great games but don't stand out in terms of plot and character development in the sea of games out at the moment. X
- Jun 7, 2020
- 50
- 22
Mine was a pacthesis game, don't really remember which one lol. Not my all-time favorite, but I do feel some nostalgia.
- Apr 1, 2026
- 226
- 184
Mine was Yo-Jin-Bo, and I still like the game (I actually replayed it a couple weeks ago), but it's not my favourite! I think the further back you go for someone playing their first otome, the less likely it'll be their favourite still. There was some slim pickings back in my day!
I don't remember what my first otome game could be, but I do know that Amnesia is my first otome game that fits the traditional visual novel model. I think the game's a good introduction to otome games in my experience but it definitely isn't my favorite.
- Mar 14, 2015
- 119
- 54
I'm quite fond of the game *Amnesia*. Its four storylines build upon one another layer by layer, culminating in a final "Truth Route" that is truly stunning—and the narrative logic holds together perfectly. The character art, CGs, and voice acting are all excellent; furthermore, the subsequent installments successfully rounded out the overarching storyline, thoroughly satisfied.
- Aug 20, 2011
- 84
- 115
I remember my veeery first otoge was Garnet Cradle, I was so entranced by it's music (and now I'm a BIIGG fan of Elements Garden) and beautiful art..
the fantasy story was soo good, and sometimes bitter sad too.. it might not be the bestest I've ever played, but definitely one of the great ones in my heart!
the fantasy story was soo good, and sometimes bitter sad too.. it might not be the bestest I've ever played, but definitely one of the great ones in my heart!
- Feb 3, 2026
- 69
- 56
my first real otome yes but i played a bunch of those interactive romances story games(werewolves haven rising my fav) and stuff like episode in high school before i knew what otome was and played it